I've been using one of these with my Mac thru a USB port for a couple of years. It has always worked reliably.
If the hard drive is good to begin with, then this device should work as a solid attachment to your computer.
Weaknesses:
A bit difficult to install a HD and line up the screws to holes, etc. but not impossible.
Summary:
Great for archiving files - you can use one of these with a number of otherwise useless hard drives just by swapping the hard drives in and out as needed.
- Easy to install
- Easy to use
- Drives do not over heat
- Durable
Weaknesses:
- Vibrates alot
- Gets hot
Summary:
I use two of these, one as a permanent drive and one to check drives I find (I have a lot) and I have never had it break down or have any issues (until I lost one power supply) the vibration on my desk and heat of the unit takes a bit to get used to.
I Have been using one of these with a Barracuda drive for 2 years now with no issues at all. The aluminum case is very attractive, portable and quiet. This drive is for backups only so high-speed access is not really an issue for me. The power switch makes it easy to turn off when not in use to save on power and drive wear. This is the best solution for an external drive - you choose the drive brand & size, this case works with all of them.